4 Best Places to Sell Guns in New Haven, CT
Want the best place to sell your guns in New Haven, CT?
A historically rich and bustling city, New Haven has a sizable population of responsible gun owners despite the state’s strict firearm laws. There’s also a lot of reputable Federal Firearms Licensees (FFLs) nearby who can not only help you understand local gun laws, but also buy used guns from you.
If you’re looking to sell a firearm in the easiest legal way possible, here are trusted FFLs operating in and around New Haven, CT.
1. Cash for Arms
Cash for Arms is a nationwide Federal Firearms Licensee (FFL) offering a simple, secure way to sell guns in New Haven, CT. We provide free, competitive market-based appraisals so you can review your gun’s value before committing to a sale.
Our online process is straightforward and hassle-free. We also provide free insured shipping directly from your doorstep and some of the highest prices on used firearms.
.webp)
Selling Process
- Provide your gun’s details.
- Accept our offer and ship your gun with our shipping label.
- Get paid through your preferred method.
Location, Hours of Operation, and Contact Information
Location: 11655 Central Pkwy, Ste 303, Jacksonville, FL 32224
.svg)
Operation Hours: 24/7 Online | Drop-offs available Mon - Fri: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
.svg)
Contact Information: (904) 977-5477 | support@cashforarms.com
.webp)
Cash For Arms Review Highlights
Chevy Ditzler | Like most people, I was extremely skeptical about selling my gun online. Let alone mailing it too and hoping it was getting to where it was suppose to. I can assure you this is a legit company and they gave me a really good offer for my AK105. My package arrived to them in a few days, and after they inspected it my payment was issued. I was an outlier and my payment took more than their usual turnaround, but they were very communicative and updated me the whole time.
E Fraaken | Legit and solid company sold a Rifle to CFA it was simple and fast process we negotiated a price that we were both happy with I shipped it and took a few days to arrive ounce it did I accepted ACH direct deposit and the funds arrived the next day ...I would recommend them to anyone trying to sell or buy (Arms)
Andy Luts | Flawless first transaction with CFA!! I can't think of anything that needs improvement or disappointed me in any way. Truly impressive, dialed-in process. I need look no further the next time I want to sell a firearm quckly and at a fair price!!
2. The Marksman Den
Just east of New Haven, The Marksman Den is a small shop with a solid selection of firearms. They also offer pistol permit classes and firearms training, making them a good option for both new and experienced gun owners.
They do purchase firearms and provide both cash and consignment options. However, due to the store’s smaller size, getting an immediate offer might take time. Consignment sales could take a bit longer to finalize.
Location, Hours of Operation, and Contact Information
Location: 85 W Main St, Branford, CT 06405
Operation Hours: Wed-Fri: 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM | Sat: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM | Sun: 10:00 AM - 3:00 PM | Mon-Tue: Closed
Contact Information: (203) 488-8550 | https://themarksmansden.com/
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Michael | My father and I stopped in a few weeks ago as we were driving by..glad we did this is a very nice well stocked store had just about one of everything!! lots of very cool antique guns as well!! Guy behind the counter was very friendly and helpful!! Will definitely be back.
Caelah-Beth Butler | My husband and I had the best experience with Art in his pistol permit safety class. He is a patient teacher, passionate about guns and gun safety, and is just a kind person. The class portion was very engaging and going to the range was a confidence-builder. We totally recommend Marksman's Den!
Brian K | I stopped in for the first time today and spent quite a while talking with the new owner, Cody. All the staff are friendly, and the shop carries a variety of inventory from the latest firearms to a good selection of milsurp and C&R firearms. I will definitely be visiting in the future.
3. The Gun Store
As one of the largest gun shops in Connecticut, The Gun Store carries an extensive inventory and offers services like FFL transfers, gunsmithing, and pistol permit classes.
They buy used firearms, offering both cash and store credit. Just note that because of their large selection, getting an offer might be a bit difficult if your gun is something they already have a lot of stock for.
Location, Hours of Operation, and Contact Information
Location: 130 Scott Rd Rear, Waterbury, CT 06705
Operation Hours: Mon - Fri: 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM | Sat: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM | Sun: 10:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Contact Information: (203) 528-3690 | https://thegunstorect.com
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Tammie Barone | Best spot around!! The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. They have a huge selection and customer service is amazing
John G | Dropped off 2 of my handguns to get night sights installed. Staff was very friendly and they have a huge selection of ammo and firearms. The gunsmith did a great job with the sight install on both of my firearms. Great place.
A W | Staff is helpful and nice. They have knowledge with the questions you ask. The selection is decent. The prices are not bad, 300$ - thousands. Colored and designed guns.
4. CT Gun LLC
Located a bit further out, CT Gun LLC is a medium-sized shop with a solid firearm inventory and a bonus—fishing supplies. It’s a good stop if you’re looking to gear up for both land and water.
They buy used firearms and offer both cash and consignment deals, making it a convenient option if you’re going near the area or planning to get some fishing supplies while offloading your guns.
Location, Hours of Operation, and Contact Information
Location: 1397 Newfield St, Middletown, CT 06457
Operation Hours: Tue - Fri: 10:00 AM - 5:30 PM | Sat: 10:00 AM - 4:00 PM | Sun - Mon: Closed
Contact Information: (860) 788-6353 | https://www.ctgunllc.com/
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Keith Mello | Great people , quick to answer questions. Knowledgeable and informative. Had no problem staying late to answer questions for me knowing I wasn’t buying that day. When I was ready to purchase a certain item the whole process was quick. I’ll definitely be buying more from here.
Ali Andre | Purchased my first ever firearm, being a Glock 19x, the gentleman was very knowledgeable and informative, honest guy, and wants to make sure everything you get is right and fair for you, this will be the only store I will be buying from
Adam Meltsner | One of my favorite gun shops around. Josh has a great selection, very reasonable prices, and definitely knows his products. Truly, a great experience shopping here.
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Conclusion
The top four places to sell a gun in New Haven, CT are Cash for Arms, The Marksman Den, The Gun Store, and CT Gun LLC. All these stores make offers for used firearms, so you may want to contact them all to compare their prices.
You can even start with us at Cash for Arms for a free online appraisal. Contact us here or at (904) 977-5477 to see what we can do for you.