4 Best Places to Sell Guns in Tallahassee, FL
Trying to find the best place to sell your guns in Tallahassee, FL?
Tallahassee, FL isn’t just full of hills and hiking trails—it’s also home to a strong firearm community. Whether your looking to downsize your collection or make some quick cash, there are plenty of potential buyers near you.
However, the safest and most legal way to sell is through a local Federal Firearms Licensee (FFL). These dealers follow strict federal procedures to ensure your transaction stays compliant and secure.
In this guide, we’ll show you your options for those by listing the top 4 places to sell a gun in Tallahassee, FL.
1. Cash for Arms
Cash for Arms is an online, federally licensed firearm dealer that offers free appraisals and insured shipping anywhere in the United States.
If you’re looking to sell a gun in Tallahassee, FL we provide competitive, market-based offers—including consignment options and same-day cash payments.
.webp)
Selling Process
- List the full details of your gun on our website.
- Accept our offer.
- Get paid on the day.
Location, Hours of Operation, and Contact Information
Location: 11655 Central Pkwy, Ste 303, Jacksonville, FL 32224
.svg)
Operation Hours: 24/7 Online | Drop-offs available Mon - Fri: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
.svg)
Contact Information: (904) 977-5477 | support@cashforarms.com
.webp)
Cash For Arms Review Highlights
James Geddes | My experience with the staff at Cash for Arms was excellent from my initial contact to receiving payment for my entire collection. Noah, Paul, Michael, and the CFA team guided me through the process, making everything easy yet thorough. They promptly answered all of my questions, and their offer was excellent. I highly recommend using Cash for Arms.
Kent Reynolds | In a day when few things are streamlined, easy, and reliable, Cash For Arms was all three. It actually surprised me how easy it was and how they have created a process that worked perfectly. In addition their communication was immediate and always helpful. Terrific customer service.
David L. Moody | I have recently had a great experience with Cash for Arms. We were able to make a deal on a rifle I had for sale. The turnaround was very quick. Everyone I connected with at Cash for Arms was great. They pay the shipping which is great. Overall, it was a great exchange. Check them out!
2. The Indoor Shooting Range
Don’t let the name fool you—though it’s primarily known as a shooting range. The Indoor Shooting Range also buys and sells firearms through its 8,000-square-foot retail store.
They accept both new and used firearms, and their staff—many of whom are certified instructors—are knowledgeable and helpful throughout the process. If you are looking to sell your guns and want to try something out in the range, this is a solid option.
Location, Hours of Operation, and Contact Information
Location: 499 Capital Cir SW, Tallahassee, FL 32304
Operation Hours: Mon - Sat: 10:00 AM - 6:30 PM | Sun: 1:00 PM - 5:30 PM
Contact Information: (850) 727-4867 | https://www.tallyindoorshooting.com
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Asharia Stallworth | My boyfriend and I took the First Time Shooting class, and AJ was awesome. He made us feel safe, comfortable, and confident the whole time. Super patient, knowledgeable, and great at explaining everything clearly. Highly recommend AJ if you’re new to shooting!
Raychel G | Fantastic ownership, great knowledgeable staff! Everyone is very friendly and are quick to help you and answer all questions. Best shooting range in town hands down! They have it all!
Misty Hart | I was highly satisfied with the training this place offers!! The staff was very friendly and nice and our gun buying experience here was excellent! Highly recommend taking the conceal carry course here. Mr. Robert was an excellent instructor!
3. Folmar’s
A family-owned pawn shop with over 30 years of experience buying and selling goods—including firearms, they offer quick cash payouts and are open to trades as well
If you want a fast and reliable way to sell your guns, they’re a solid option. Just keep in mind that, as with most pawn shops, offers are usually low.
Location, Hours of Operation, and Contact Information
Location: 808 N Monroe St, Tallahassee, FL 32303
Operation Hours: Mon - Fri: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM | Sat: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM | Sun: Closed
Contact Information: (850) 224-6836 | http://folmars.com
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Collin Woods | John is the reason this shop stands out. He’s professional, knowledgeable, and makes every customer feel valued—not just like another transaction. Whether you're buying, selling, or just browsing, he takes the time to help without pressure. Top-notch service all around. Highly recommend!
Luke Dodge Folmar’s offers great prices, a welcoming atmosphere, and standout service—especially from John. He’s knowledgeable about both jewelry and firearms, and always takes time to help customers get the best deal. Friendly, helpful, and professional—ask for John!
Laila Nicholson | Had a great experience at Folmar's. John was a great help in finding me the perfect trinkets for my new apartment. Such a kind fella! This young man has gone above and beyond the expectations of a pawn shop broker. Thanks John!
4. Red Hills Arms
Serving the Tallahassee community since 2014, Red Hills Arms has built a strong local following. They offer both cash and consignment options for used firearms.
If you are looking to sell your guns—and also have knives, parts, or other weapons to offload—this is a good option. If you’re trying to offload a collection, you may also ask them to come to your place. They offer this service from North Florida to South Georgia.
Location, Hours of Operation, and Contact Information
Location: 1401 Market St Unit #2, Tallahassee, FL 32312
Operation Hours: Tue - Fri: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM | Sat: 11:00 AM - 5:00 PM | Mon - Sun: Closed
Contact Information: (850) 597-8128 | https://redhillsarms.com/
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Matthew Golaub | This shop has personally helped me and my Fiancée get Into the gun community. From both of our pistols to my ar-15 they have taught us so much, and saved us money!!! Shop here when possible.
Stephen Mayers | Bought my rifle from here 3 years ago and had a great experience. Encountered my first issue with it and Seth fixed it super quick. He and Gray provided great customer service. Thanks guys!
Michael C | Red Hills Arms is a great shop. The staff is professional, friendly, and welcoming. I've made a number of purchases and transfers with these guys, and it has been an excellent experience, every time. They have a nice selection of firearms and accessories, and should be able to assist you, whether you are new to firearms or an expert.
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Customer Reviews and Experiences
Conclusion
The best places to sell a gun in Tallahassee, FL are Cash for Arms, The Indoor Shooting Range, Folmar’s, and Red Hills Arms. to get the best offer, we recommend contacting each one to compare your options.
You can also start with us at Cash for Arms for a free appraisal. Contact us here or at (904) 977-5477 to see what we can offer.
And if you’re looking for other places to sell guns in Florida, you can check our guides for other cities: like Jacksonville, Miami, Tampa, Orlando, or Saint Petersburg.