How Much is a Kimber II Custom 1911 (2026 Value Update)

How We Calculate Used Kimber Custom II Values

The value of your Kimber Custom II depends on its condition, specific variant, and any included accessories or upgrades that enhance its functionality or collectibility.

Condition and Values

Condition affects resale value for Kimber Custom II guns. These pistols are precision-built with tight tolerances, so proper care and maintenance help preserve both performance and collector appeal.

You can visit local gun shops for in-person appraisals, though some may charge a fee. Sellers can also get a free gun appraisal from us for a quick estimate online.

To see how we professionally evaluate your firearm (for free) and turn that condition into a payout, view our 3-step selling process for a guaranteed FFL offer.

Here's a general guide you can use to gauge your pistol's value:

Like-New or Mint

• Top resale prices for Custom II models
• Unfired
• No cosmetic damage
• Perfect mechanical function and finish

Excellent

• Around 10% less than mint
• Very light use with minimal wear
• Barely visible cosmetic damage
• Fully functional with no issues

Very Good

• Around 20% less than mint
• Light carry wear on high points
• Some cosmetic damage
• Fully functional with no issues

Good

• Around 30% less than mint
• Heavy use and maintained
• Inevitable damage from use
• Fully functional with no issues

Fair

• Around 40% less than mint
• Heavy use and unmaintained
• Heavy marks from neglect
• May need minor gunsmithing

Poor

• Around 50% less than mint
• Extensive use and left
• Heavy wear and tear marks, possible rusted or dented
• Function may be compromised

Use these tiers to estimate your Kimber Custom II's value once you've assessed its overall condition.

How We Appraise Kimber Custom II Model

The Kimber Custom II lineup has numerous variants, from the standard blued model to tactical law enforcement versions and premium two-tone finishes. These can command significantly different values in today's market.

Identifying your specific variant is crucial before selling. Check the model markings, finish type, and features, then compare them to the variants below to find your pistol's current market value.

(Standard) Kimber Custom II Value

The average used Kimber Custom II is worth $335 to $665. A new Kimber Custom II sells for around $950 at retail.

The standard Custom II features a matte black finish with black synthetic grips, fixed low-profile sights, and a 5" match-grade barrel. This is the baseline model that set the standard for production 1911s.

Kimber Tactical Custom II Value

The average used Kimber Tactical Custom II is worth $365 to $820. A new Kimber Tactical Custom II sells for around $1,317 at retail.

The Tactical Custom II uses a lightweight aluminum frame with steel slide. It includes night sights, ambidextrous thumb safety, and extended magazine well for reduced carry weight.

Kimber Tactical Custom II Engraved Patriot Value

The average used Kimber Tactical Custom II Engraved Patriot is worth $690 to $1400.

The Tactical Custom II uses a lightweight aluminum frame with steel slide. It includes night sights, ambidextrous thumb safety, and extended magazine well for reduced carry weight.

This is a model that holds value well. Because it’s a premium firearm in the line, we use a secure gun shipping and buying system to ensure every transaction is fully insured and legally compliant.

Kimber Eclipse Custom II Value

The average used Kimber Eclipse Custom II is worth $400 to $800. A new Kimber Eclipse Custom II sells for around $1,477 at retail.

The Eclipse Custom II features a bi-tone finish with stainless steel slide and black oxide frame. It includes tritium night sights and silver/black laminated grips for a distinctive appearance.

Kimber Custom Two-tone II Value

The average used Kimber Custom Two-tone II is worth $285 to $565.

The Two-Tone variant features a brush-polished stainless steel frame with a matte black slide. It includes rosewood grips and maintains all standard Custom II features with a distinctive two-tone appearance.

Kimber Custom TLE II Value

The average used Kimber Custom TLE II is worth $375 to $720. A new Kimber Custom TLE II sells for around $1,000 at retail.

The Tactical Law Enforcement (TLE) II was designed for LAPD SWAT. It features tritium night sights, 30 LPI front strap checkering, and tactical enhancements for law enforcement use.

Kimber Stainless II Value

The average used Kimber Stainless II is worth $375 to $760. A new Kimber Stainless II sells for around $1,042 at retail.

The Stainless II features all-stainless steel construction with satin finish. This variant offers superior corrosion resistance and enhanced durability for carry in humid environments.

How Accessories Affect What We Pay for Your Kimber II

Accessories can affect a Kimber Custom II's resale value, though results vary by quality and buyer interest.

Factory Kimber accessories and premium upgrades from recognized manufacturers typically enhance value, while generic aftermarket parts often don't add significant appeal.

If you're having trouble finding a buyer interested in your complete setup, contact us. We frequently make offers for 1911 pistols with accessories and magazines included.

Original Box and Papers

Having the original Kimber box and its papers demonstrates provenance and proper care. You can try offering them to your buyer for proper valuation.

Value: Around $10 to $30 for matching box and papers.

Optics and Sights

Quality tritium night sights from Trijicon, Meprolight, or factory Kimber night sight upgrades add functionality for low-light use. Adjustable target sights from reputable manufacturers can also enhance value, particularly for competition-oriented shooters seeking precision adjustments.

Value: Around 30% to 50% of the accessory's retail value.

Extended Magazines

Factory Kimber magazines maintain better value than aftermarket alternatives. Having multiple factory 7-round or 8-round magazines adds convenience. Buyers generally love having more magazines.

Value: Around $15 to $30 per additional factory magazine.

The Process to Sell a Kimber II to Us

Selling a Kimber II shouldn't be complicated. We provide a streamlined process that handles the heavy lifting for you.

• Step 1: Get an instant quote based on your gun’s specific model and condition.
• Step 2: Accept our offer and ship your gun with our prepaid label.
• Step 3: Get paid the same day we validate it.